En EspaƱol Get Your Free Case Review Today! Main Menu
713-587-9668
In Houston
800-580-9121
Toll Free

Supreme Court Denies Wal-Mart Class Certification

The United States Supreme Court dismissed a class-action lawsuit against Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., which claimed that the retailer had discriminated against 1.5 million female workers.

Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the 5-4 majority in Dukes v. Wal-Mart, said that "In a company of Wal-Mart's size and geographical scope, it is quite unbelievable that all managers would exercise their discretion in a common way without some common direction." The opinion further suggested that short of being able to point to an actual company policy of discriminating, such massive class actions could not be certified.

The entire court agreed that the class action suit as it was constituted could not seek monetary damages because it sought individual awards of back pay for some of the women.

Nevertheless, four justices (Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan) disagreed with the majority's dismissal of the entire case. As Justice Ginsburg highlighted, "Women fill 70% of the hourly jobs in the retailer's stores, but make up only '33% of the management employees ... The higher one looks in the organization, the lower the percentage of women.'" Based on this and other statistical evidence, the dissenters believed that the suit could possibly have been maintained under another class action standard, which requires only that common class questions "predominate" over issues affecting individuals. The majority's decision, however, foreclosed this possibility.

Commentators contend that the ruling is not only a victory for Wal-Mart but also may help to shield other large employers from similar claims of discrimination that rely upon statistics.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us Today
And Get Your Free Case Review

Logo: Texas Best Lawyers Logo: Texas Super Lawyers - Texas Bar College Logo: Lead Counsel Rated Logo: Houston's Top Lawyers Logo: American Trial Lawyers Association
Logo: Abraham Watkins Best Lawyers in America Best Lawyers Award Badge Logo: American Board of Trial Advocates - Million Dollar Advocates Forum Logo: The Best Lawyers in America

As Seen On:

Logo: CNN Logo: Houston Chronicle Logo: Houston Public Media Logo: ABC 13 Logo: USA Today Logo: KHOU 11 Logo: KPRC 2 Logo: Fox 26 Logo: Telemundo Logo: Univision