En EspaƱol Get Your Free Case Review Today! Main Menu
In Houston
Toll Free

Supreme Court Rules Against Another Patient

Photo of Jay Jackson

The Texas Supreme Court recently threw out another case brought by a patient. In the case of Turtle Healthcare Group, L.L.C. d/b/a Fred's Pharmacy v. Linan, et al., ___ S.W.3d ___(Tex. 2011)(2/25/11), the family of a woman who was dependent upon a ventilator asked the provider for extra supplies and batteries because of an approaching hurricane. Shortly after power was lost, ventilator was found not operating and the woman was dead.

The family brought suit, alleging several theories. One included a claim that the provider neglected to supply or include adequate batteries. Since that was not considered a "medical malpractice" claim, no expert report was provided.

The Supreme Court permanently dismissed case. It held that all claims against a health care provider must be brought as "malpractice," and therefore must have an expert report.

Here, all of the claims "are based upon the same underlying facts," viz., negligent maintenance and operation of the ventilator. "[P]ermitting the same underlying facts to give rise to both types of claims would effectively negate the procedures and limitations of the TMLA." Accordingly, if the same set of facts gives rise to claims under more than one legal theory, unlike other areas of the law the claims under other legal theories cannot be pursued and the case can only be brought as malpractice.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us Today
And Get Your Free Case Review

Logo: Texas Best Lawyers Logo: Texas Super Lawyers - Texas Bar College Logo: Lead Counsel Rated Logo: Houston's Top Lawyers Logo: American Trial Lawyers Association
Logo: Abraham Watkins Best Lawyers in America Logo: American Board of Trial Advocates - Million Dollar Advocates Forum Logo: The Best Lawyers in America

As Seen On:

Logo: CNN Logo: Houston Chronicle Logo: Houston Public Media Logo: ABC 13 Logo: USA Today Logo: KHOU 11 Logo: KPRC 2 Logo: Fox 26 Logo: Telemundo Logo: Univision